Restrict access to some journals, but not all

accounting v16

1 Odpowiedz

2617 Widoki

Geert Janssens

Hi, I'm trying to restrict access to some journals for a given internal user. The user is allowed to access the other journals.

I have tried to create a new group for the Accounting application. This group inherits from the Administrator group, but I have added a new access rule that restricts access to all but 2 account journals.

This works to remove the journals from the accounting dashboard for this user. However I run into problems when this user tries to process a payment for a vendor bill. The payment wizard shows up fine and the list of journals is also filtered to exclude the two journals. However when the user selects a different journal from the default selected account I get an error. The log entry corresponding to this error is:

INFO db-name odoo.addons.base.models.ir_rule: Access Denied by record rules for operation: read on record ids: [12, 23], uid: 4, model: account.journal
INFO db-name odoo.addons.base.models.ir_rule: Access Denied by record rules for operation: read on record ids: [12, 23], uid: 4, model: account.journal
INFO db-name odoo.addons.base.models.ir_rule: Access Denied by record rules for operation: read on record ids: [12], uid: 4, model: account.journal
WARNING db-name odoo.http: Due to security restrictions, you are not allowed to access 'Journal' (account.journal) records.

Records: name-of-restricted-journal (id=12)
User: name-of-restricted user (id=4)

This restriction is due to the following rules:
name of rule I created

Contact your administrator to request access if necessary.

This is unexpected. I just want to two journals not listed in the drop down and in the dashboard, but my rule seems to prevent the user from selecting any of the non-restricted journals as well.

What am I missing ?

Cybrosys Techno Solutions Pvt.Ltd

Hi,

The issue occurs because Odoo’s record rules apply globally, not just in list views or dropdowns. When you restrict access to certain journals, Odoo still needs to read those records internally while processing payments or validating journal entries. Since your record rule blocks access completely, the system throws an Access Denied error even if the restricted journals aren’t being directly used. Essentially, the rule doesn’t just hide journals; it prevents Odoo from reading them anywhere in the backend.

To fix this, the recommended approach is to avoid using strict record rules for journal visibility and instead manage access through journal groups and user groups. You can assign specific journals to particular user groups in the journal’s configuration, which hides unwanted journals in dropdowns and dashboards without breaking background operations.

If you must use record rules, you can modify them to allow internal reads by relaxing the domain or using conditions that only limit UI visibility, but this can be tricky to maintain. In short, controlling access via user groups rather than record rules is the safest and cleanest way to restrict journals without affecting payment processing or other accounting workflows.

Hope it helps

Geert Janssens

Autor

Thank you for your answer.

I have found the menu option "Journal groups" in Accounting. I can create a group that excludes the two journals I want to restrict access to.

However I have not yet found how to tie this to a user group. I don't see an setting in the individual journal's configuration page to set a user group for this. I don't see anything on the journal group's config page either. I have also looked at the user group configuration pages, but nothing seems to point at where I can set a journal group.

Can you explain that part a bit more in detail ? Thank you.

Geert Janssens

Autor

Hi, I haven't gotten an answer yet to my follow-up question. Can you please provide more details on your first answer ? There are bits missing, or not matching what I see in my environment... Does your solution require additional modules to be installed ? If so, which ones ?

Ray Carnes (ray)

Unfortunately the part of this answer discussing "assigning journals to user groups" is wrong - neither Journals nor Journal Groups have any relationship with User Groups - likely this part of the answer was hallucinated by an AI ChatBot.

Geert Janssens

Autor

I was afraid of that already :(
Do you see a way of achieving what I'm after ?

Podoba Ci się ta dyskusja? Dołącz do niej!

Stwórz konto dzisiaj, aby cieszyć się ekskluzywnymi funkcjami i wchodzić w interakcje z naszą wspaniałą społecznością!

Zarejestruj się

Powiązane posty	Odpowiedzi	Widoki
『✦Iberia✦Costa~Rica✦』¿Cómo comunicarse con Iberia Costa Rica? accounting	0 cze 26	51
Prevent auto-validation of bank journal transaction to vendor bill matching accounting	3 cze 26	383
in odoo 19 the amount does not appear distributed Profits/Losses after closing the balance accounting	2 cze 26	2935
AVCO Vendor Return Creates Inventory Valuation Difference – Correct Accounting Treatment? accounting	1 cze 26	1579
Receipt accounting	2 cze 26	2246

To pytanie dostało ostrzeżenie

Podoba Ci się ta dyskusja? Dołącz do niej!