Se rendre au contenu
Odoo Menu
  • Se connecter
  • Essai gratuit
  • Applications
    Finance
    • Comptabilité
    • Facturation
    • Notes de frais
    • Feuilles de calcul (BI)
    • Documents
    • Signature
    Ventes
    • CRM
    • Ventes
    • PdV Boutique
    • PdV Restaurant
    • Abonnements
    • Location
    Sites web
    • Site Web
    • eCommerce
    • Blog
    • Forum
    • Live Chat
    • eLearning
    Chaîne d'approvisionnement
    • Inventaire
    • Fabrication
    • PLM
    • Achats
    • Maintenance
    • Qualité
    Ressources Humaines
    • Employés
    • Recrutement
    • Congés
    • Évaluations
    • Recommandations
    • Parc automobile
    Marketing
    • Marketing Social
    • E-mail Marketing
    • SMS Marketing
    • Événements
    • Marketing Automation
    • Sondages
    Services
    • Projet
    • Feuilles de temps
    • Services sur Site
    • Assistance
    • Planification
    • Rendez-vous
    Productivité
    • Discussion
    • Intelligence artificielle
    • Internet des Objets
    • VoIP
    • Connaissances
    • WhatsApp
    Applications tierces Odoo Studio Plateforme Cloud d'Odoo
  • Industries
    Commerce de détail
    • Librairie
    • Magasin de vêtements
    • Magasin de meubles
    • Supermarché
    • Quincaillerie
    • Magasin de jouets
    Restauration & Hôtellerie
    • Bar et Pub
    • Restaurant
    • Fast-food
    • Maison d’hôtes
    • Distributeur de boissons
    • Hôtel
    Immobilier
    • Agence immobilière
    • Cabinet d'architecture
    • Construction
    • Gestion immobilière
    • Jardinage
    • Association de copropriétaires
    Consultance
    • Cabinet d'expertise comptable
    • Partenaire Odoo
    • Agence Marketing
    • Cabinet d'avocats
    • Aquisition de talents
    • Audit & Certification
    Fabrication
    • Textile
    • Métal
    • Meubles
    • Alimentation
    • Brasserie
    • Cadeaux d'entreprise
    Santé & Fitness
    • Club de sports
    • Opticien
    • Salle de fitness
    • Praticiens bien-être
    • Pharmacie
    • Salon de coiffure
    Commerce
    • Homme à tout faire
    • Matériel informatique & support
    • Systèmes photovoltaïques
    • Cordonnier
    • Services de nettoyage
    • Services CVC
    Autres
    • Organisation à but non lucratif
    • Agence environnementale
    • Location de panneaux d'affichage
    • Photographie
    • Leasing de vélos
    • Revendeur de logiciel
    Parcourir toutes les industries
  • Communauté
    Apprenez
    • Tutoriels
    • Documentation
    • Certifications
    • Formation
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    Renforcer l'éducation
    • Programme éducatif
    • Business Game Scale-Up!
    • Rendez-nous visite
    Obtenir le logiciel
    • Téléchargement
    • Comparez les éditions
    • Versions
    Collaborer
    • Github
    • Forum
    • Événements
    • Traductions
    • Devenir partenaire
    • Services pour partenaires
    • Enregistrer votre cabinet comptable
    Nos Services
    • Trouver un partenaire
    • Trouver un comptable
    • Rencontrer un conseiller
    • Services de mise en œuvre
    • Références clients
    • Assistance
    • Mises à niveau
    Github Youtube Twitter Linkedin Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Obtenir une démonstration
  • Tarification
  • Aide
Vous devez être inscrit pour interagir avec la communauté.
Toutes les publications Personnes Badges
Étiquettes (Voir toutl)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
À propos de ce forum
Vous devez être inscrit pour interagir avec la communauté.
Toutes les publications Personnes Badges
Étiquettes (Voir toutl)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
À propos de ce forum
Aide

BOM Routings with version 14

S'inscrire

Recevez une notification lorsqu'il y a de l'activité sur ce poste

Cette question a été signalée
mrproutingsBOM
2 Réponses
13153 Vues
Avatar
Craig Steffen

In versions prior to 14, Routings were defined on the BOM level. Work Centers and Operations were set up under Configuration. Various combinations of the Work Centers/Operations could form a defined Routing that could then be assigned to a BOM. 

With version 14, it appears the defined Routing functionality has gone away. Instead, each Routing is effectively created on the BOM level. I'm assuming Odoo got rid of the standardized routing function in order to achieve the flexibility showcased in version 14. This new flexibility lets you modify almost anything on the BOM and MO at any stage. Previously you defined the standard Work Centers and Operations through Configuration and pulled them through to the BOM via Routings. Now Routings are gone and you effectively push the Work Centers and Operations from the BOM backwards to the list in Configuration. Since every Operation and Work Order can be specific to a BOM, I don't understand the purpose of even having a "standard" list under Configuration.

While manufacturers probably need flexibility, it would seem that many (or even most) would have standardized routes in their production processes. Depending on the BOM, they could select the appropriate route. Many manufacturers might only have one route.

In our case, every MO is unique and built only once. Every BOM is unique in terms of materials and built only once. However, the Work centers/Operations (Routings or manufacturing steps) are the same on every production run.

Is there anyway we can have the standardized Routings functionality without staying with version 13 or will this require customization? 

 

2
Avatar
Ignorer
Agustin Barreto

Hi Craig,

did you solve this? any workaround to keep using defined operations? I have the same problem than you.

cheers and thanks in advance,

Agustin.-

Ray Carnes (ray)

See https://www.odoo.com/forum/help-1/why-are-manufacturing-operations-not-selectable-from-a-pre-defined-list-they-are-typed-in-in-v14-179203

Avatar
Zbigniew Łukasiak
Meilleure réponse

Hello

I'm not sure if I understand the problem exactly, but I will describe how it looks in my case.
My company produces unique products in the workshop based on technical drawings from the customer.
We produce, for example, details such as "turned and milled detail".
Everyone is different, but the material is always a steel rod (of different diameter and steel grade). The route (in short) is always the same:
1 cut
2 turning
3 milling
4 manual processing
I have a BOM template for this type of detail.
I duplicate it, replace the raw material in the BOM with the correct one and enter its correct quantity, and then enter the correct operation times 1-4.
I have similar templates for other types of manufactured products.

When duplicating a BOM, all operations defined in it are duplicated - thanks to this I have the functionality of "standard operations".
In my opinion, this method is more effective than the one known from previous versions where duplicating the BOM did NOT duplicate the list of operations (routes).
Rewriting the route with a long list of operations selected from the list was also not convenient in older versions of Odoo - it was also a place of errors.

1
Avatar
Ignorer
Avatar
Steffy
Meilleure réponse

Odoo 14 does not support one operation for Multiple BOMs or Routings. You need to create different operations for different BOMs. As it is a little time consuming but it is better as the type of material used, time taken in a particular operation can be different for different products. For example you have an operation named "Packing" and you want to add this operation to 2 different BOMs like "Bag" and "Chair". But the packing material and packing time will be different for these 2 BOMs. So it is better to have 2 different Operations as the specifications for these operations need to be different according to the requirements of the BOMs.

Hope it helps..!!


Steffy 

Junior Odoo Consultant

Tel: +353 1 886 5684 (IE) +44 121 285 5684 (UK)  +91 964 381 7554 (IN)

 

Target Integration | CRM • ERP • Cloud

Website | LinkedIn | Twitter | Facebook | YouTube | Instagram

0
Avatar
Ignorer
Craig Steffen
Auteur

Thanks for the response Steffy. I understand that the time for a given operation may differ on what product is being produced. For this reason, each operation on a BOM may need to be edited for the amount of time required to produce the product. However, if the only variable is the time of the operation, and not the operation itself, it doesn't make sense to me to create new operations each time.

In your example, there is a common operation of "Packing" for producing a "Bag" or a "Chair." While the time of "packing" may be different whether producing a "bag" or a "chair" the operation still is "packing" nonetheless. It would seem much more intuitive to have standardized operations that are adjusted on each BOM as needed rather than create new operations each time a new BOM is set up. Let's say I wanted to run a report on the "Packing" operation's efficiency across multiple BOMs and MOs - since the operation is created unique to each BOM there would be a problem if one BOM called the operation "Packing," while another was incorrectly typed in as "Paking," or another used a term of "Compiling" when these all represent the same physical work being done in the manufacturing process.

While definitely less flexible, I do think the routings framework within version 13 is actually more logical and intuitive than the "blank slate" version 14, especially for manufacturers who have a relatively standardized assembly process for all the different products that are produced.

The only solution for bringing back a routing framework in the version 14 environment appears to be the use of BOM templates.

Vous appréciez la discussion ? Ne vous contentez pas de lire, rejoignez-nous !

Créez un compte dès aujourd'hui pour profiter de fonctionnalités exclusives et échanger avec notre formidable communauté !

S'inscrire
Publications associées Réponses Vues Activité
How to produce multiple products from a single raw material
mrp mo BOM
Avatar
0
déc. 24
1777
BOM:s, variants and routings (version 12) Résolu
mrp routings variants
Avatar
Avatar
1
déc. 19
5973
Odoo 8 MRP/routing help needed
procurement mrp routings
Avatar
0
mai 16
5353
In MRP, how to have a list of procedures to follow, and track that they are followed?
mrp routings working_center
Avatar
1
mars 15
8117
How to do a distribute a single workorder in multiple workcentres ? Résolu
mrp routings workorder working_center
Avatar
Avatar
1
oct. 21
5898
Communauté
  • Tutoriels
  • Documentation
  • Forum
Open Source
  • Téléchargement
  • Github
  • Runbot
  • Traductions
Services
  • Hébergement Odoo.sh
  • Assistance
  • Migration
  • Développements personnalisés
  • Éducation
  • Trouver un comptable
  • Trouver un partenaire
  • Devenir partenaire
À propos
  • Notre société
  • Actifs de la marque
  • Contactez-nous
  • Emplois
  • Événements
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Clients
  • Informations légales • Confidentialité
  • Sécurité.
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk Slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español Svenska ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo est une suite d'applications open source couvrant tous les besoins de votre entreprise : CRM, eCommerce, Comptabilité, Inventaire, Point de Vente, Gestion de Projet, etc.

Le positionnement unique d'Odoo est d'être à la fois très facile à utiliser et totalement intégré.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now