Zum Inhalt springen
Odoo Menü
  • Anmelden
  • Jetzt gratis testen
  • Apps
    Finanzen
    • Buchhaltung
    • Rechnungsstellung
    • Spesenabrechnung
    • Tabellenkalkulation (BI)
    • Dokumente
    • E-Signatur
    Verkauf
    • CRM
    • Verkauf
    • Kassensystem – Shop
    • Kassensystem – Restaurant
    • Abonnements
    • Vermietung
    Websites
    • Website-Builder
    • E-Commerce
    • Blog
    • Forum
    • Livechat
    • E-Learning
    Lieferkette
    • Lager
    • Fertigung
    • PLM
    • Einkauf
    • Wartung
    • Qualität
    Personalwesen
    • Mitarbeiter
    • Personalbeschaffung
    • Abwesenheiten
    • Mitarbeiterbeurteilung
    • Personalempfehlungen
    • Fuhrpark
    Marketing
    • Social Marketing
    • E-Mail-Marketing
    • SMS-Marketing
    • Veranstaltungen
    • Marketing-Automatisierung
    • Umfragen
    Dienstleistungen
    • Projekte
    • Zeiterfassung
    • Außendienst
    • Kundendienst
    • Planung
    • Termine
    Produktivität
    • Dialog
    • Künstliche Intelligenz
    • IoT
    • VoIP
    • Wissensdatenbank
    • WhatsApp
    Apps von Drittanbietern Odoo Studio Odoo Cloud-Plattform
  • Branchen
    Einzelhandel
    • Buchladen
    • Kleidergeschäft
    • Möbelhaus
    • Lebensmittelgeschäft
    • Baumarkt
    • Spielwarengeschäft
    Essen & Gastgewerbe
    • Bar und Kneipe
    • Restaurant
    • Fast Food
    • Gästehaus
    • Getränkehändler
    • Hotel
    Immobilien
    • Immobilienagentur
    • Architekturbüro
    • Baugewerbe
    • Immobilienverwaltung
    • Gartenarbeit
    • Eigentümervereinigung
    Beratung
    • Buchhaltungsfirma
    • Odoo-Partner
    • Marketingagentur
    • Anwaltskanzlei
    • Talentakquise
    • Prüfung & Zertifizierung
    Fertigung
    • Textil
    • Metall
    • Möbel
    • Speisen
    • Brauerei
    • Firmengeschenke
    Gesundheit & Fitness
    • Sportklub
    • Brillengeschäft
    • Fitnessstudio
    • Therapeut
    • Apotheke
    • Friseursalon
    Handel
    • Handyman
    • IT-Hardware & -Support
    • Solarenergiesysteme
    • Schuster
    • Reinigungsdienstleistungen
    • HLK-Dienstleistungen
    Sonstiges
    • Gemeinnützige Organisation
    • Umweltschutzagentur
    • Plakatwandvermietung
    • Fotostudio
    • Fahrrad-Leasing
    • Software-Händler
    Alle Branchen ansehen
  • Community
    Lernen
    • Tutorials
    • Dokumentation
    • Zertifizierungen
    • Schulung
    • Blog
    • Podcast
    Bildung fördern
    • Bildungsprogramm
    • Scale-Up! Planspiel
    • Odoo besuchen
    Software anfragen
    • Herunterladen
    • Editionen vergleichen
    • Releases
    Zusammenarbeiten
    • Github
    • Forum
    • Veranstaltungen
    • Übersetzungen
    • Partner werden
    • Dienstleistungen für Partner
    • Buchhaltungsfirma registrieren
    Services anfragen
    • Partner finden
    • Buchhalter finden
    • Einen Experten treffen
    • Implementierungsservices
    • Kundenreferenzen
    • Support
    • Upgrades
    Github Youtube Twitter Linkedin Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Eine Demo erhalten
  • Preise
  • Hilfe
Sie müssen registriert sein, um mit der Community zu interagieren.
Alle Beiträge Personen Abzeichen
Stichwörter (Alle anzeigen)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Über dieses Forum
Sie müssen registriert sein, um mit der Community zu interagieren.
Alle Beiträge Personen Abzeichen
Stichwörter (Alle anzeigen)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
Über dieses Forum
Hilfe

Limit API key scope without creating a new active user.

Abonnieren

Erhalten Sie eine Benachrichtigung, wenn es eine Aktivität zu diesem Beitrag gibt

Diese Frage wurde gekennzeichnet
securityAPIAI
1 Antworten
946 Ansichten
Avatar
Rutger Hofste

I've just had a great conversation with Odoo Support that confirmed something I'd been hoping wasn't the case:

"Odoo counts every user in the system, including bot or service accounts, as a billable user. API keys are always tied to a user, so they inherit that user's access rights. There is currently no built-in way to create scoped API tokens with limited permissions independent of a user."

I'm posting this because I'd love to hear how other implementation partners and customers are handling the same problem in practice.

The use cases I'm dealing with on a single Odoo instance:

  1. AI assistant via MCP Pro (ChatGPT / Claude) — read-heavy, occasional writes on sale.order and crm.lead
  2. Public website form — must only create on crm.lead, with specific extra fields
  3. Cron job that syncs some stats from our SaaS into Odoo daily
  4. n8n workflow that comments on new partners after enrichment
  5. A Python script for one-off data imports — full access, but only run on-demand

Each one needs a different scope. Principle of least privilege says they should each have minimal permissions. Native Odoo gives me two options:

  • One technical user per integration — clean separation, but each one is a billable user (≈€30-40/month in our region). Five integrations = €150-200/month extra, purely for governance — the bot uses no UI, no email, no chat, no calendar, no human-seat features.
  • One shared "integration user" cheap, but every call collapses to the same user_id in the audit log. No way to distinguish "who did what" between five very different consumers. Not great when something goes wrong.

For enterprise customers I find option 1 economically unviable and option 2 weak on governance. Both feel wrong.

My questions to the community:

  1. Have you found a way to scope API keys (per-model, per-method, per-IP, per-time-window) without spinning up additional billable users? OCA modules, custom modules, anything?
  2. For per-call attribution on a shared user, are you doing anything beyond inspecting auditlog.http.request.user_context for self-asserted tags? I'm exploring patching res.users.apikeys._check_credentials to carry the matched key id forward into request.session — then the audit log can show which key called, not just which user. Curious if anyone has done this in production.
  3. Has anyone successfully negotiated a non-billable "integration user" / "service account" exception with Odoo SA for headless automation?
  4. Is there a planned change in Odoo 20 to either (a) allow API key scoping or (b) introduce a non-billable service-account user type? I haven't seen anything in the Odoo Experience 2025 keynote or the 20 preview material, but maybe I missed it.

I'm building an open-source AI governance module (pan_mcp_pro_governance, free on the App Store) and want to make sure I'm not solving a problem someone has already cracked. Patches and ideas very welcome.

Thanks

0
Avatar
Verwerfen
Benjamin Ruoff
I completely agree with this.

The way Odoo currently handles this feels pretty absurd to me. For API access, automation, and integrations, scoped permissions and proper attribution should be basic platform capabilities. Tying every API key directly to a full user account is, in my opinion, a questionable architectural decision. It does not really fit modern expectations around least privilege, auditability, and governance.

I find Viveks suggetion with the OCA plugin great but what makes it even more frustrating is that even if someone builds a proper solution as a custom module, you cannot install it on Odoo Online without moving to Odoo.sh. At some point, it really starts to feel less like a technical limitation and more like an upsell trap.  

For a system that positions itself as a serious business platform with strong integration capabilities, proper service accounts or scoped API tokens should not be a luxury. Not every technical access is a human user, and not every API key should inherit the rights of a full account.

Avatar
Vivek Kundaliya
Beste Antwort

This is an excellent question that highlights a real gap in Odoo's current architecture. Unfortunately, there is no native built-in solution for scoped API keys without additional billable users in Odoo.


The workarounds are exactly what you've described: either multiple billable users (expensive) or a shared integration user (weak audit trail).


For OCA modules, check: https://github.com/OCA/server-auth - there may be something in the "auth" modules that can help with key-level attribution.


I can provide a custom module that implements scoped API key management for Odoo - allowing you to create API keys with specific model/method restrictions, IP whitelisting, and per-key audit logging without requiring additional billable users. Reach me at custom@trewac.com

1
Avatar
Verwerfen
Rutger Hofste
Autor

Great suggestion. The OCA community indeed has great repos. However there was no support for v19 and api keys were linked to users, not scopes (user roles). I merged two oca repos (user roles and audit), and added functionality so you can optionally limit the scope for your api key (and therefore mcp) without adding new users and without changing what the user can do. https://github.com/pantalytics/odoo-mcp-pro-governance

Rutger Hofste
Autor

Perhaps you can check out if your modules could improve this one (feel free to do a PR)

Diskutieren Sie gerne? Treten Sie bei, statt nur zu lesen!

Erstellen Sie heute ein Konto, um exklusive Funktionen zu nutzen und mit unserer tollen Community zu interagieren!

Registrieren
Verknüpfte Beiträge Antworten Ansichten Aktivität
AI governance (Data governance)
security AI
Avatar
Avatar
1
Mai 26
859
OdooPilot v0.1.0 — free open-source AI agent for Odoo (Telegram + WhatsApp, Claude/GPT-4/Groq/Ollama) — feedback and feature requests welcome
AI
Avatar
0
Apr. 26
27
Introducing AI tools which can be used in Odoo version 17, 18 and 19
AI
Avatar
0
Apr. 26
1514
Local Odoo 19 Database: Inventory not showing on Hand?
security
Avatar
0
Apr. 26
5
Database stock product names are different than in the Odoo UI
API
Avatar
Avatar
1
März 26
923
Community
  • Tutorials
  • Dokumentation
  • Forum
Open Source
  • Herunterladen
  • Github
  • Runbot
  • Übersetzungen
Dienstleistungen
  • Odoo.sh-Hosting
  • Support
  • Upgrade
  • Individuelle Entwicklungen
  • Bildung
  • Buchhalter finden
  • Partner finden
  • Partner werden
Über uns
  • Unsere Firma
  • Markenwerte
  • Kontakt
  • Karriere
  • Veranstaltungen
  • Podcast
  • Blog
  • Kunden
  • Rechtliches • Datenschutz
  • Sicherheit
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk Slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español Svenska ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo ist eine Suite von Open-Source-Betriebsanwendungen, die alle Bedürfnisse Ihres Unternehmens abdecken: CRM, E-Commerce, Buchhaltung, Lager, Kassensystem, Projektmanagement etc.

Das einzigartige Wertversprechen von Odoo ist, dass es gleichzeitig sehr einfach zu bedienen und voll integriert ist.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now