Skip to Content
Odoo Menú
  • Registra entrada
  • Prova-ho gratis
  • Aplicacions
    Finances
    • Comptabilitat
    • Facturació
    • Despeses
    • Full de càlcul (IA)
    • Documents
    • Signatura
    Vendes
    • CRM
    • Vendes
    • Punt de venda per a botigues
    • Punt de venda per a restaurants
    • Subscripcions
    • Lloguer
    Imatges de llocs web
    • Creació de llocs web
    • Comerç electrònic
    • Blog
    • Fòrum
    • Xat en directe
    • Aprenentatge en línia
    Cadena de subministrament
    • Inventari
    • Fabricació
    • PLM
    • Compres
    • Manteniment
    • Qualitat
    Recursos humans
    • Empleats
    • Reclutament
    • Absències
    • Avaluacions
    • Recomanacions
    • Flota
    Màrqueting
    • Màrqueting Social
    • Màrqueting per correu electrònic
    • Màrqueting per SMS
    • Esdeveniments
    • Automatització del màrqueting
    • Enquestes
    Serveis
    • Projectes
    • Fulls d'hores
    • Servei de camp
    • Suport
    • Planificació
    • Cites
    Productivitat
    • Converses
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • IoT
    • VoIP
    • Coneixements
    • WhatsApp
    Aplicacions de tercers Odoo Studio Plataforma d'Odoo al núvol
  • Sectors
    Comerç al detall
    • Llibreria
    • Botiga de roba
    • Botiga de mobles
    • Botiga d'ultramarins
    • Ferreteria
    • Botiga de joguines
    Food & Hospitality
    • Bar i pub
    • Restaurant
    • Menjar ràpid
    • Guest House
    • Distribuïdor de begudes
    • Hotel
    Immobiliari
    • Agència immobiliària
    • Estudi d'arquitectura
    • Construcció
    • Property Management
    • Jardineria
    • Associació de propietaris de béns immobles
    Consultoria
    • Empresa comptable
    • Partner d'Odoo
    • Agència de màrqueting
    • Bufet d'advocats
    • Captació de talent
    • Auditoria i certificació
    Fabricació
    • Textile
    • Metal
    • Mobles
    • Menjar
    • Brewery
    • Regals corporatius
    Salut i fitness
    • Club d'esport
    • Òptica
    • Centre de fitness
    • Especialistes en benestar
    • Farmàcia
    • Perruqueria
    Trades
    • Servei de manteniment
    • Hardware i suport informàtic
    • Sistemes d'energia solar
    • Shoe Maker
    • Serveis de neteja
    • Instal·lacions HVAC
    Altres
    • Nonprofit Organization
    • Agència del medi ambient
    • Lloguer de panells publicitaris
    • Fotografia
    • Lloguer de bicicletes
    • Distribuïdors de programari
    Browse all Industries
  • Comunitat
    Aprèn
    • Tutorials
    • Documentació
    • Certificacions
    • Formació
    • Blog
    • Pòdcast
    Potenciar l'educació
    • Programa educatiu
    • Scale-Up! El joc empresarial
    • Visita Odoo
    Obtindre el programari
    • Descarregar
    • Comparar edicions
    • Novetats de les versions
    Col·laborar
    • GitHub
    • Fòrum
    • Esdeveniments
    • Traduccions
    • Converteix-te en partner
    • Services for Partners
    • Registra la teva empresa comptable
    Obtindre els serveis
    • Troba un partner
    • Troba un comptable
    • Contacta amb un expert
    • Serveis d'implementació
    • Referències del client
    • Suport
    • Actualitzacions
    Github Youtube Twitter Linkedin Instagram Facebook Spotify
    +1 (650) 691-3277
    Programar una demo
  • Preus
  • Ajuda
You need to be registered to interact with the community.
All Posts People Badges
Etiquetes (View all)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
About this forum
You need to be registered to interact with the community.
All Posts People Badges
Etiquetes (View all)
odoo accounting v14 pos v15
About this forum
Ajuda

Disallow negative stock at subcontracting locations

Subscriure's

Get notified when there's activity on this post

This question has been flagged
subcontractingv15NegativeStockKeepItSimple
1 Respondre
6411 Vistes
Avatar
Ricardo Gross

Using the subcontracting feature, it's possible to receive the subcontracted products before you have replenished the subcontractor with the required components.

How to allow the receipt of the subcontracted products only after the components have been resupplied at the subcontractor location?

Thanks

BR

Ricardo

(I know there are the very nice OCA module that solves the question, but how to solve it in a SaaS environment?)


4
Avatar
Descartar
Chris Parker

Did you ever find a solution to this, Ricardo?

Avatar
Ray Carnes (ray)
Best Answer
We don't recommend this.
Allowing negative inventory (with good monitoring) reveals problems that need fixing—like mismatched transactions, theft, or process lags. If you block users, some issues may just get hidden instead of addressed.

If negative inventory is disallowed, users may:

  • Start inflating inventory with fake Receipts
  • Delay validating transfers in Odoo
  • Create unnecessary inventory adjustments
  • Adjust transfers to the quantity available but ship the original quantity requested
  • Might ship or transact using similar or incorrect SKUs
  • Give up on Odoo and use manual or shadow systems

Each of these makes reconciliation even harder and introduces audit/compliance risks.

Your Users are smart, empower them with good tools and get out of their way. Train them on what to do when inventory goes negative and create robust processes to resolve the issues it uncovers.


This is not a complete solution but a prototype. Work with your Odoo Digital Advisor or Odoo Partner if you don't have the skills to create this yourself and to ensure it does not need modifications to work in your database.


1) In Developer Mode, visit Settings --> Technical --> Automation --> Automation Rules

2) Create an Automation Rule like this:


3) Add an Action of type Execute Code like this:

accuracy = env["decimal.precision"].precision_get("Product Unit of Measure")
for record in records:
    diff = round(record.quantity, accuracy)
    if (diff < 0 and record.product_id.is_storable and
            record.location_id.usage in ["internal", "transit"]):
        raise UserError(f'You need {-diff} more {record.product_id.name}(s) to complete this Transfer!')


You will then see an blocking message like this:


Be ready to ARCHIVE this Automation Rule if it blocks Users from doing things they need to do. 




1
Avatar
Descartar
Chris Parker

Ray, you're right that those things can come up but that's a personell issue not a technical one. With a more strict system, staff are subverting policy but the ERP is stable and JEs flow well. Staff behavior can be dealt with later.

Complex systems like ERPs should not be so flexible. In some cases, it's good and right to be rigid and have strict guardrails. We're currently on day five of trying to undo a problem with prematurely receiving finished goods before completing the component MO and resupplying. Staff know they must complete the MO+resupply first but it was forgotten this time and they immediately went on to consume those finished goods in other MOs and ship+invoice pending orders. Now we have journal entries of which we can't make sense.

We didn't contact Odoo support or our partner because we thought we'd seen this before and a quick fix would be found but now more time has gone by than expected and we're still not sure.

Turns out this scenario is slightly different than last time and that's why we're struggling. That _and_ being <1 year of Odoo experience and troubleshooting.

Having said all that, thanks for your proposed solution! I will try implementing it once we get this worked out.

Chris Parker

To be clear, I'm not advocating for all negative movements to be clocked. I'm advocating specifically for Odoo to reject the receipt of subcontracted goods before the underlying MO(s) have been completed and the subcontractor has been resupplied. It should be safe for Odoo to assume that because the finished good is able to be received, it must also be true that the subcontractor was resupplied.

Perhaps a middle ground is, "You are about to receive a subcontracted item for which the subcontractor has not been resupplied. This may cause an imbalance in your system. Do you wish to proceed?"

The operator would then have the opportunity to go and complete the unfinished MO and Resupply.

Enjoying the discussion? Don't just read, join in!

Create an account today to enjoy exclusive features and engage with our awesome community!

Registrar-se
Related Posts Respostes Vistes Activitat
Link between Manufacturing Order and subcontractor
mrp subcontracting v15
Avatar
0
d’abr. 25
2911
Pricelists for product category with minimal quantity conditions
pricelist productcategory v15 KeepItSimple
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
4
de febr. 24
5506
Different home page for mobile access
mobile homepage v15 KeepItSimple
Avatar
0
d’abr. 23
3682
(v14) How do I get a subcontracted product to be delivered directly to an external address chosen in a Purchase Order? Solved
dropship subcontracting deliveries-warehouse KeepItSimple
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
3
d’oct. 22
4899
Edit header and footer of email templates
header footer emailtemplate v15 KeepItSimple
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
3
de març 25
10684
Community
  • Tutorials
  • Documentació
  • Fòrum
Codi obert
  • Descarregar
  • GitHub
  • Runbot
  • Traduccions
Serveis
  • Allotjament a Odoo.sh
  • Suport
  • Actualització
  • Desenvolupaments personalitzats
  • Educació
  • Troba un comptable
  • Troba un partner
  • Converteix-te en partner
Sobre nosaltres
  • La nostra empresa
  • Actius de marca
  • Contacta amb nosaltres
  • Llocs de treball
  • Esdeveniments
  • Pòdcast
  • Blog
  • Clients
  • Informació legal • Privacitat
  • Seguretat
الْعَرَبيّة Català 简体中文 繁體中文 (台灣) Čeština Dansk Nederlands English Suomi Français Deutsch हिंदी Bahasa Indonesia Italiano 日本語 한국어 (KR) Lietuvių kalba Język polski Português (BR) română русский язык Slovenský jazyk Slovenščina Español (América Latina) Español Svenska ภาษาไทย Türkçe українська Tiếng Việt

Odoo és un conjunt d'aplicacions empresarials de codi obert que cobreix totes les necessitats de la teva empresa: CRM, comerç electrònic, comptabilitat, inventari, punt de venda, gestió de projectes, etc.

La proposta única de valor d'Odoo és ser molt fàcil d'utilitzar i estar totalment integrat, ambdues alhora.

Website made with

Odoo Experience on YouTube

1. Use the live chat to ask your questions.
2. The operator answers within a few minutes.

Live support on Youtube
Watch now